Crandall Public Library

May
24

Board of Trustees Meeting

Holden Room

Wednesday, May 24 2023

4:30pm - 6:00pm EDT

Illustration of a two people discussing at a table

Nothing to see yet. Check back for updates.

Agenda

  1. Call to Order
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
    4:30 pm EDT
  2. Public Comment
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
  3. Correspondence and Press
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
    1. Incident Reports
  4. Department Reports
    1. Assistant Director
      Guinevere Forshey profile image
    2. Adult Services
      Jennifer Boyer profile image
    3. Children’s Department
      Julia Farrar profile image
      1. Teen Department, F. Toth (written report)
    4. Circulation Services
      Caitlin Costa profile image
    5. Development Department
      Michelle Barrios profile image
    6. Folklife Department
      Todd DeGarmo profile image
    7. Facilities 
      Jeremy Dickinson profile image
  5. Friends of Crandall Library
    Linda McDowell profile image
  6. Approval of Board of Trustees Minutes: April 26, 2023 
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
  7. Treasurer’s Report, April 2023
    David Barcomb profile image
  8. Approval of Claims Auditor Reports, April 2023
    David Barcomb profile image
  9. Committee(s) Reports
    1. Finance Committee
      David Barcomb profile image

      Joint Finance/Personnel 2024 Budget Meeting - Held May 4, 2023.

    2. Personnel Committee
      Elizabeth Hogan profile image
      1. Approval of the status change for Autumn Goerner, Librarian I, from part-time to full-time effective May 22, 2023.
      2. Approval of the Appointment of Merycarol Roods, Page, effective May 24, 2023, at $15.25/hour.
      3. Approval of the Permanent Appointment of Amanda Franzoni, Folklife Manager of Research & Special Collections, effective May 25, 2023.

        Warren County Civil Service Exam State #63978 Local #11221.

      4. Acceptance of the Retirement of Karen Hilfiger, Reference Librarian II, effective May 31, 2023. Karen has worked for the Library since March 2004.
  10. SALS
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
  11. Director’s Report & Action Items
    Kathy Naftaly profile image
    1. Approval of Butler Roland Mays Architects, LLP scope of improvements to Childrens, Teen and Internet Room, not to exceed $40,000 (purchases on NYS contract).
  12. Old Business
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
  13. New Business
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
    1. Resolution against Book Bans
  14. Executive Session (if necessary)
  15. Adjournment
    Margaret Shapiro profile image
  16. The next Board Meeting is on June 28, 2023, at 4:30 p.m. in the Community Room (lower level).

Minutes Tab

Crandall Public Library
org logo

Board of Trustees Meeting

Wed May 24, 2023 8:30 PM - 10:00 PM UTC

Attendance:

Trustees: Ms. Shapiro, Ms. Caimano, Ms. Bartlett, Mr. Goralski, Ms. Nichols, Mr. Antis, Ms. Hogan, Ms. Vanderminden, Mr. Barcomb, Ms. Eddy, Dr. Blood, and Mr. Toomey.

Absent: Excused: Ms. Nemer, Ms. Swanson, and Ms. Johnson.

Staff: Ms. Naftaly, Ms. Forshey, Ms. Farrar, Ms. Costa, Ms. Barrios, Mr. Dickinson, Mr. DeGarmo, Ms. Winters, and Ms. Durett-Clapper.

Guest: Linda McDowell, Friends of Crandall Public Library.

Call to Order

President Shapiro called the meeting to order at 4:31 p.m. Quorum was established.

Public Comment

No public comment.

Correspondence and Press

The Board passed around this month's correspondence and press.

Incident Reports

The Board reviewed this month's incident reports.

Department Reports

Assistant Director

Ms. Forshey thanked the Friends; the monies they gave for a staff holiday party provided lunch for staff after an all-staff meeting today. Coach's Corner Food Truck offered a variety of lunch choices; it was wonderful, and everyone enjoyed it. Mr. Dickinson and Ms. Berg installed the new Pollinator Garden in the Park this week; they planted native plants to attract pollinators; the garden is in partnership with ADKAction.[1] June 20-25, 2023, is National Pollinator Week, and we have programming events planned; ADKAction has supplied books, bookmarks, action kits, and seeds.

[1] https://www.adkaction.org/

Adult Services

Excused; written report submitted.

Children’s Department

Ms. Farrar discussed the April report, including programming for the April School Break and National Library Week. All Children's Department staff attended the New York Library Association (NYLA) Youth Services Section (YSS) Spring Conference in Lake George; it was great that all staff could attend the conference. Ms. Farrar discussed the programs they enjoyed the most, which included ones they felt were very beneficial to the Department. The Department is working on school outreach to promote the Beanstack Summer Reading Program. Watch for the summer calendar shortly; Ms. Ziegler will have it ready soon.

Ms. Naftaly informed the Board that Ms. Farrar was responsible for the YSS Spring Conference as a member of the NYLA YSS Team; kudos to Ms. Farrar for all the hard work!

Teen Department, F. Toth 

Written report submitted.

Circulation Services

Ms. Costa stated the Circulation Department had another great month in April, with over 3,400 hold items; we are seeing an increase in people coming in, including from surrounding towns. Ms. Costa outlined patron transactions, materials sent, and materials received, by the library, in the April written report. The Department continues to issue new library cards to patrons, which they are always happy to provide. Since going fine-free in January, over 1,000 lost material items have been returned. At Mr. Antis's request, Ms. Costa will break down new library card transactions by the town/municipality for next month's report.

Development Department

Ms. Barrios reported on the SALS Annual Meeting held on May 15, 2023, in Saratoga Springs, where Crandall Public Library won the 2022 Program of the Year Award for the George Takei event; we are very excited to have received the award. Mr. Antis, Ms. Caimano, Ms. Shapiro, and Ms. Forshey also attended the SALS meeting. The Development Department is currently working on possibly changing directions for the fundraiser in the fall, a topic during tonight's executive session. 

Folklife Department

Mr. DeGarmo shared a pass-around packet; the information was not ready to be added to Boardable. Mr. DeGarmo also shared the sad news that Ralph Lee, Artistic Director of the Mettawee River Theatre Company, passed away last week; on a more positive note, the Folklife Center at Crandall Public Library was mentioned several times in his obituary in the New York Times.[2] Mr. DeGarmo gave details of the upcoming Folklife Center 30th. Anniversary Festival in City Park on July 25, 2023, he supplied Board members with yard signs promoting the event.

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/16/arts/ralph-lee-dead.html

Ms. Shapiro shared information with the Board about the Westport (Connecticut) Library's recording studio; they are adding a "record label" to their roster of services.[3]

[3] https://ilovelibraries.org/article/library-releases-vinyl-album-of-local-music-recorded-at-its-own-studio/

Facilities 

Mr. Dickinson has been working with Mark, the representative from Fusion Systems Engineering; he could not attend tonight's meeting but will be at the June meeting to discuss the Boiler Redesign Project. Mr. Dickinson explained the different options presented by Fusion Systems Engineering, a discussion ensued, and Mr. Antis requested information on the project be uploaded to Boardable before the June meeting. 

Friends of Crandall Library

Ms. McDowell shared bookmarks promoting the Books on Carts In the Park Sales, the first sale is on June 14, 2023, and there will be music by the Warren County Ramblers; they hope for a good turnout. The second and third sales are July 12 and August 9. The book sales are held from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. The Friends are stopping book donations for June to focus on the summer book sales. Ms. McDowell shared a sample Memorandum of Agreement (MOU) with the Friends Board; Ms. Shapiro, Ms. Bartlett, and a couple of members from the Friends Board will meet to put an MOU between the Friends and the Library in place. Ms. Forshey and Ms. McDowell will share the information at the Friends' next board meeting. For complete book sale details, visit the website.[4]

[4] https://www.crandalllibrary.org/calendar-and-events/book-sale/

Approval of Board of Trustees Minutes: April 26, 2023 

c. Ad Hoc By-Laws Committee 

The Ad Hoc By-Laws Committee members are Ms. Bartlett (Chair), Ms. Shapiro, Ms. Caimano, Ms. Vanderminden, and Ms. Swanson. The Committee will review and revise the current By-Laws of Crandall Public Library adopted on June 27, 2018. 
*Item c. added as a revision to the original draft minutes under New Business.

Motion to approve the Board of Trustee’s Minutes of April 26, 2023, with the above revision, was made by Mr. Antis, seconded by Ms. Hogan. Motion carried unanimously.    

Treasurer’s Report, April 2023

Mr. Barcomb reported the revenues are 63.4%; as of April 2023, expenses are 28.8%. April is 33.3% of the 2023 budget year. Mr. Barcomb explained the budget revisions as outlined in the report.

 A Motion to accept the Treasurer Report and approve the Budget Revisions was made by Mr. Barcomb, seconded by Ms. Caimano. Motion carried unanimously.    

Approval of Claims Auditor Reports, April 2023

Acceptance of the Claims Auditor Reports for April 2023 bills and payroll; there were no issues in April.

Motion to accept the Claims Auditor Reports was made by Mr. Barcomb, seconded by Ms. Bartlett. Motion carried unanimously.  

Committee(s) Reports

Finance Committee

Joint Finance/Personnel 2024 Budget Meeting - Held May 4, 2023.

Mr. Barcomb reported that the joint Committees meet in April and May; they will meet again on June 13, 2023, at 10:00 a.m. in the Holden Room; they are making good progress on the 2024 Budget. 

Personnel Committee

Approval of the status change for Autumn Goerner, Librarian I, from part-time to full-time effective May 22, 2023.

Approval of the Appointment of Merycarol Roods, Page, effective May 24, 2023, at $15.25/hour.

Approval of the Permanent Appointment of Amanda Franzoni, Folklife Manager of Research & Special Collections, effective May 25, 2023. 

Warren County Civil Service Exam State #63978 Local #11221.

Acceptance of the Retirement of Karen Hilfiger, Reference Librarian II, effective May 31, 2023. Karen has worked for the Library since March 2004.

Motion to approve the four Personnel items was made by Ms. Hogan, seconded by Mr. Goralski. Motion carried unanimously.   

SALS

Ms. Shapiro discussed the SALS Annual Meeting held on May 15, the Library Trustees and staff who attended (listed in Ms. Barrios's report), and SALS Director Sara Dallas's fiery speech and chant: "Free People Read Freely." Mr. Antis added that he spoke with Lauren Moore, New York State Librarian, who was the event's guest speaker; they discussed the cost of eBooks; New York State is negotiating with publishers on the cost of eBooks for schools and, hopefully, libraries will be able to receive a lower price as well.

Director’s Report & Action Items

Ms. Naftaly started by passing along a patron's request to thank the Board for the Fine Free Policy; the patron; was unable to return items for a couple of days passed the due date and was grateful there were no fines to pay. Today an all-staff meeting was held; Ms. Naftaly discussed that Warren County issued a State of Emergency due to the migrant crisis, and she informed staff that anyone, including the migrants, is free to use our services, the literacy services, and is welcome here. In keeping with being welcoming, we will have a pride display for June, and Ms. Naftaly will be staffing a Library table at the Glens Falls Pride Event on June 4, 2023; she wants everyone in our community to understand that the Library is for everybody, we are welcoming to all. Ms. Naftaly discussed a Department of Energy Grant, which, if awarded, could assist with the cost of the Boiler Redesign Project; there are upcoming informational meetings, and more information will be forthcoming. Ms. Naftaly explained the action item.

Action Item

Approval of Butler Roland Mays Architects, LLP scope of improvements to Children's, Teen, and Internet Room, not to exceed $40,000 (purchases on NYS contract).

Motion to approve the Action item was made by Ms. Caimano, seconded by Mr. Antis. Motion carried unanimously.    

Old Business

Ms. Caimano gave an update on the Trustee terms ending on December 31, 2023. The Queensbury Trustees, Ms. Nemer, Mr. Goralski, and Dr. Blood, are running again. Ms. Eddy from Moreau and Ms. Vanderminden from Glens Falls will not be running again; there is an interested candidate from Glens Falls, and the current Moreau Trustees will spread the word to try and find an interested candidate from Moreau. Signed petitions are due by July 13, 2023.

New Business

Resolution against Book Bans

The resolution was shared with the Trustees through Boardable.

Motion to approve the resolution was made by Ms. Bartlett, seconded by Mr. Goralski. Motion carried unanimously.    

Executive Session 

Discuss the change to the 2023 Henry & Betsy Crandall Award recipients and the Director's evaluation. No actions were taken from the executive session. The Ad Hoc Henry & Betsy Crandall Award Committee will meet again, and more information will be forthcoming for this year's award recipient(s).

Motion to enter into Executive Session was made by Mr. Antis, seconded by Dr. Blood. Motion carried unanimously. Executive Session entered at 5:11 p.m.  
Motion to exit the Executive Session was made by Ms. Caimano, seconded by Mr. Goralski. Motion carried unanimously. Executive Session exited at 5:36 p.m.  

Adjournment

Motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Antis, seconded by Ms. Nichols. Motion carried unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 5:37 p.m.    

Respectfully submitted,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     

Reed Antis, Secretary of the Board of Trustees of Crandall Public Library

Recorded by Melissa Durett-Clapper, Administrative Assistant

Attendance

Members

Name Attendance

Reed Antis

David Barcomb

Amy Bartlett

Suzanne Blood

Barbara Caimano

Melissa Durett-Clapper

Louise Eddy

Guinevere Forshey

John Goralski

Elizabeth Hogan

Megan Johnson

Kathy Naftaly

Dale Nemer

Donna Nichols

Margaret Shapiro

Diane Swanson

Michael Toomey

Christina Vanderminden

Guest Members

Name Attendance

Michelle Barrios

Jennifer Boyer

Caitlin Costa

Todd DeGarmo

Jeremy Dickinson

Julia Farrar

Linda McDowell

Stephanie Winters

powered by  

Take mission-critical meetings from friction to focus with Boardable.

Get Started